Wiktionary:Votes/2009-03/Transwikis from other Wiktionaries/Version 1
Transwikis from other Wiktionaries
[edit]- Voting on:
- Either:
- asking a developer to enable transwikis from other Wiktionaries, or
- not enabling these.
- Either:
- instructing importers to use this feature only for entries that will be re-formatted immediately after transwiki, and deleting such entries if they are not re-formatted immediately (since they can always be re-transwiki'd if need be), or
- not instructing this (i.e., leaving it to importers' discretion).
- For entries, either:
- using the Transwiki: namespace as a "staging ground" (like with transwikis from Wikipedia), or
- importing them directly into the main namespace (since they'll be reformatted immediately), or
- not specifying this (i.e., leaving it to importers' discretion).
- Either:
- Note that #3 only affects entries, not templates and appendices and such. (Feel free to express an opinion on this, but adding it to the vote seems like overkill.)
- This is a modified approval vote. You may vote for any combination of the options below; the one with the greatest approval will be accepted, provided that it has the approval of at least 75% of those voting. If no option has the approval of at least 75% of those voting, then option A (no change) will win by default.
- Technically speaking, there are 12 permutations of the above, but only 6 of these make sense, since we can't specify policy without having the tool, and we can't use the main namespace for transwikis that won't get reformatted immediately. Only the 6 sensible permutations are listed below.
Vote ends: 23:59 16 April 2009 (UTC)Vote started: 0:00 18 March 2009 (UTC)- Vote created: —RuakhTALK 18:43, 11 March 2009 (UTC)
- Discussion:
Option A: No change (#1.2)
[edit]If you approve of not enabling this tool, enter {{subst:support}}
on the next blank line in this section. (This does not preclude you from supporting other options as well.)
Option B: Enable tool, no further policy (#1.1, #2.2, #3.3)
[edit]If you approve of enabling this tool without specifying any further policy, enter {{subst:support}}
on the next blank line in this section. (This does not preclude you from supporting other options as well.)
Option C: Enable tool for immediate reformatting (#1.1, #2.1, #3.3)
[edit]If you approve of enabling this tool, specifying that entries be re-formatted immediately (or else deleted), but not specifying what namespace must be used, enter {{subst:support}}
on the next blank line in this section. (This does not preclude you from supporting other options as well.)
Option D: Enable tool for immediate reformatting, Transwiki: namespace (#1.1, #2.1, #3.1)
[edit]If you approve of enabling this tool, specifying that entries be transwikied into the Transwiki: namespace and re-formatted immediately (or else deleted), enter {{subst:support}}
on the next blank line in this section. (This does not preclude you from supporting other options as well.)
Option E: Enable tool for immediate reformatting, main namespace (#1.1, #2.1, #3.2)
[edit]If you approve of enabling this tool, specifying that entries be transwikied into the main namespace and re-formatted immediately (or else deleted), enter {{subst:support}}
on the next blank line in this section. (This does not preclude you from supporting other options as well.)
Option F: Enable tool, Transwiki: namespace (#1.1, #2.2, #3.1)
[edit]If you approve of enabling this tool, specifying that entries be transwikied into the Transwiki: namespace, but not specifying that they have to be re-formatted immediately, enter {{subst:support}}
on the next blank line in this section. (This does not preclude you from supporting other options as well.)
Oppose
[edit]"Oppose" votes do not make sense for this kind of vote. If you disapprove of enabling this tool, enter {{subst:support}}
on the first blank line under "Option A" above.
Abstain
[edit]If you don't want to vote, you can enter {{subst:abstain}}
on the next blank line in this section. Or not.
Decision
[edit]- This vote never took place, because it was superseded by [[Wiktionary:Votes/2009-03/Transwikis from other Wiktionaries]]. —RuakhTALK 11:27, 21 June 2010 (UTC)