Citations:Outer Manchuria: difference between revisions

From Wiktionary, the free dictionary
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Content deleted Content added
→‎Outer Manchuria in Russia: <!--{{sic|1858}}--> I guess that he was referring to the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Aigun ?
2004 Wikipedia Edit. Basis: "We do not quote other Wikimedia sites[7][8] (such as Wikipedia), but we may use quotations found on them (such as quotations from books available on Wikisource)." is an overbroad misstatement of https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Wiktionary:Votes/pl-2008-04/WMF_jargon and https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Wiktionary:Votes/pl-2010-06/WMF_jargon_accepted_when_it_meets_CFI-- yes, you can't WMF sites for CFI, but there is a place for quoting WMF as here, the oldest usage
Line 2: Line 2:
===Outer Manchuria in Russia===
===Outer Manchuria in Russia===
{{en-timeline
{{en-timeline
| 2000s=2006 2009 2010s 2022 2023
| 2000s=2004 2006 2009 2010s 2022 2023
}}
}}
* {{quote-web
|en
|date=10 May 2004
|author=62.6.139.11
|title=Outer Manchuria
|archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20230502112345/https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Outer_Manchuria&diff=prev&oldid=3543741
|work={{w|English Wikipedia}}
|url2=https://archive.is/lXO4H
|text=It was ceded by the {{w|Manchu Empire}} to {{w|Russia}} in two stages and from 1860 to 1920 was, as {{w|Russian Manchuria}}, part of the {{w|Russian Empire}}. From 1920 to 1925 '''Outer Manchuria''' was occupied by the {{w|Japanese}} and briefly united with {{w|Inner Manchuria}} under {{w|Japanese}} domination.{{...}}In 1959 tension arose between {{w|Chinese}} {{w|Inner Manchuria}} and {{w|Russian}} '''{{w|Outer Manchuria}}''' over the interpretation of the treaties of {{w|Aigun}} and {{w|Peking}}. This was as much an attempt to undo {{w|European}} {{w|colonialism}} as an ideological split between {{w|Mao Tse-tung}} and {{w|Khrushchov}}.}}
* {{quote-book
* {{quote-book
|en
|en

Revision as of 11:31, 2 May 2023

English citations of Outer Manchuria

Outer Manchuria in Russia

2004 2006 2009 2010s 2022 2023
ME « 15th c. 16th c. 17th c. 18th c. 19th c. 20th c. 21st c.
  • 2004 May 10, 62.6.139.11, “Outer Manchuria”, in English Wikipedia[1], archived from the original on 2023-05-02[2]:
    It was ceded by the Manchu Empire to Russia in two stages and from 1860 to 1920 was, as Russian Manchuria, part of the Russian Empire. From 1920 to 1925 Outer Manchuria was occupied by the Japanese and briefly united with Inner Manchuria under Japanese domination. [] In 1959 tension arose between Chinese Inner Manchuria and Russian Outer Manchuria over the interpretation of the treaties of Aigun and Peking. This was as much an attempt to undo European colonialism as an ideological split between Mao Tse-tung and Khrushchov.
  • 2006, East Asia: Seventh Report of Session 2005-06[3], volume II, House of Commons Foreign Affairs Committee, page Ev 9-Ev 10, Ev 11:
    Q35 Mr Horam: What area are we talking about where the pipelines have to go through?
    Professor Wall: What we used to call Outer Manchuria; the provinces around Manchuria which go down to Vladivostok—those areas—and Sakhalin Island, from where oil and gas is still coming. [] The newspapers are full of references to the "yellow peril"; there is a strong anti-Chiense sentiment at that level; they are worried about them coming and, in the North East, at least, this hundred years of humilitation thing is still very strong—that Outer Manchuria is Chinese and should be given back.
  • 2009, Christopher Meyer, Getting Our Way: 500 Years of Adventure and Intrigue: The Inside Story of British Diplomacy[4], London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, page 181:
    In particular, Elliot found himself confronted by a redoubtable opponent in Count Nikolai Pavlovich Ignatyev, the Russian Ambassador to the Sublime Porte. Ignatyev was cunning, agile and bold. He had had adventures aplenty and narrow escapes in Central Asia, where he had sought to build Russian influence. A particularly nimble piece of diplomacy had led to his acquiring Outer Manchuria from the Chinese Emperor.
  • 2010, John Vaillant, “Markov”, in The Tiger: A True Story of Vengeance and Survival[5] (Adventure/Nature), →ISBN, →LCCN, →OCLC, page 59:
    Two years later, Czar Alexander II went a step further and coerced the Chinese into signing the Treaty of Peking, thereby adding another slice of Outer Manchuria—what is now Primorye and southern Khabarovsk Territory—to the Russian empire. In the mid-1960s, it seemed as if Mao might try to get them back.
  • 2010, William A. Callahan, “Where Is China?: The Cartography of National Humiliation”, in China: The Pessoptimist Nation[6], Oxford University Press, published 2012, →ISBN, →OCLC, pages 113, 240:
    Other critiques of the Sino—Russian border continue to percolate among China’s netizens, including items on the PRC’s premier search engine Baidu, which rename the Russian Far East as “Outer Manchuria.” This Web site marks Outer Manchuria as an area of lost territory on a national humiliation-style map, and the text explains that it has been China’s sovereign territory “since ancient times,” and was lost when it “was invaded and occupied by Czarist Russia.”⁵⁴
    54. In Chinese the area is usually called Outer Northeast (wai dongbei) and in English, Outer Manchuria. But the Web site makes clear that they are both referring to the same lost territory. (http://baike.baidu.com/view/173829.htm; accessed March 10, 2008). Also see the Chinese Wikipedia site, which is even more detailed and has a colored map that marks lost territories in red. (http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%A4%96%E6%9D%B1%E5%8C%97; accessed March 10, 2008).
  • 2011, Henry Kissinger, “From Preeminence to Decline”, in On China[7], New York: Penguin Press, →ISBN, →LCCN, →OCLC, page 68:
    For these services Moscow exacted a staggering territorial price: a broad swath of territory in so-called Outer Manchuria along the Pacific coast, including the port city now called Vladivostok.¹⁴ In a stroke, Russia had gained a major new naval base, a foothold in the Sea of Japan, and 350,000 square miles of territory once considered Chinese.
  • 2012 February 21, Frank Jacobs, “Manchurian Trivia”, in The New York Times[8], →ISSN, →OCLC, archived from the original on 2022-07-29, Opinion Pages‎[9]:
    Russian settlers took possession of the fringes of the Chinese world, de facto annexations that were ratified by a series of “unequal treaties” [8], the Treaty of Aigun of 1858 and the Russo-Chinese Convention of Peking of 1860, which established the easternmost part of the present-day border between China and Russia [9].
    [9] Establishing what is now known as Russia’s Far East but is still referred to by some in China as Outer Manchuria. Basically, the Russian territory south of the Stanovoy Mountains, a 500-mile-long range that forms the watershed between the Arctic and Pacific Oceans and that until 1858 constituted the border between Russia and China.
  • 2012 September 22, Frank Jacobs, Parag Khanna, “The New World”, in The New York Times[10], →ISSN, →OCLC, archived from the original on 2020-11-11, page 10[11]:
    China Gobbles Up Siberia
    Russia’s greatest geopolitical fear is fed by a very plausible scenario — China, populous and resource-hungry, taking over large chunks of Siberia, part of Russia’s failing and emptying East. Hundreds of thousands of Chinese have already crossed the border at the Amur River and set up trading settlements, intermarrying with Russians and Siberia’s native nomadic minorities. Russia has a nuclear arsenal with which to fend off formal threats to its sovereignty, but the demographic imbalance is to Russia’s disadvantage and could accelerate the economic shift in China’s favor. Russia’s far eastern outpost of Vladivostok is ever more distant from Moscow. Will it become a Russian enclave in a re-Sinofied “Outer Manchuria,” like Kaliningrad, 5,000 miles away on the Baltic Sea, a Soviet fragment stranded inside the European Union?
  • 2012 September 30, Parag Khanna, “The new Silk Road is made of iron—and stretches from Scotland to Singapore”, in Quartz[12], archived from the original on 02 May 2023:
    Before Britain ruled its empire on which the sun never set, Russia had become the largest contiguous territorial power since the Mongols, stretching from Eastern Europe to North America (Alaska) by 1866. Railway expansion enabled Tsar Alexander II to invade outer Manchuria in 1868, and leverage Central Asia and Siberia for supplying Russia’s World War I efforts.
  • 2013 March 21, “Ahead of Xi's visit, China web users deluge Russia blog with insults”, in NDTV, Agence France-Presse[13], archived from the original on 2015-11-07[14]:
    Others pointed to old territorial disputes - a large area of far eastern Russia was once Chinese, but ceded to the Russian Empire by the Treaty of Peking in the mid-19th century, and there were military clashes in 1969 over a border island.
    Officially the rows have been settled, but one poster said: "Return Outer Manchuria! Take back that party!"
  • 2014, David Eimer, “The Arctic Borderlands”, in The Emperor Far Away: Travels at the Edge of China[15], Bloomsbury USA, →ISBN, →OCLC, →OL, page 279:
    In 1858, the Treaty of Aigun formalised the division of Manchuria. Everything north of what the Russians call the Amur River and the Chinese the Heilongjiang, or Black Dragon River, was assigned to Russia. Two years later, more Manchu lands went north under the Treaty of Peking. In all, Russia acquired a million square kilometres of Outer Manchuria. It is a massive area. Stretching from the present Sino-Russian border to the shores of the Sea of Okhotsk, it includes what are now the major cities of the Russian Far East — Vladivostok, Khabarovsk and Blagoveshchensk — yet the tsar’s army barely had to fire a shot to attain it.
  • 2015 July 15, Lilia Shevtsova, “Bad Romance”, in Brookings Institution[16], archived from the original on 2018-11-28, Op-Ed:
    For starters, China still nurses historical grievances toward Russia. Why should China stoop to buy commodities from its own Outer Manchuria, which was only ceded to Russia in the 19th century as a result of a series of humiliating treaties that Russia imposed on China? Are the Chinese really that forgiving? Henry Kissinger doesn’t think so: “Chinese leaders had not forgotten the series of ‘unequal treaties’ extorted for a century to establish the Russian possession of its Far East maritime provinces. . . ”(On China, Penguin Books, 2011, pp. 98–9). []
    Meanwhile, there are a lot of signs pointing to the fragility of the Kremlin’s “we are friends with China” construct. In June 2015 news spread that Russia’s Zabaikalski region (part of the old Chinese Outer Manchuria) promised to grant about 300,000 hectares of land to the Chinese company Huae Xinban under a 49-year lease for mere peanuts—less than $5 a hectare. Simultaneously, a draft law has been submitted to the Russian State Duma to guarantee the Chinese sovereignty over the rented territory; the same Kremlin that is so desperately defending Russian sovereignty from the malicious West is selling it for peanuts to China.
  • 2018, “Progress and Empire 1850-1914”, in History of the World: Map by Map[17], First American edition, DK, →ISBN, →OCLC, page 246:
    From 1858, a weakening Qing Empire ceded Outer Manchuria to Russia—an area from which it had previously been excluded by the Treaty of Nerchinsk (1689). Russia founded Vladivostok, a relatively ice-free port and, in 1898, leased the Liaodong Peninsula from China, gaining the warm-water port of Port Arthur. Alarmed by Japan’s growing interest in China, Russia occupied Southern Manchuria but was defeated in the Russo-Japanese War (1904-1905) and abandoned its imperial ambitions in the area.
  • 2019 February, Angela E. Stent, Putin's World: Russia Against the West and with the Rest[18], →ISBN, →LCCN, →OCLC, page [19]:
    After praising the border agreement, Deng led the Soviet foreign minister into a room where a map of China lay on the table. The map showed Outer Manchuria, which forms the Russian Primorsky Krai province, as Chinese, not Russian, territory.
  • 2022, Janusz Bugajski, “Neighborhood Impact”, in Failed State: A Guide to Russia’s Rupture[20], Jamestown Foundation, →ISBN, →LCCN, →OCLC, page 397:
    The Treaty of Good-Neighborliness and Friendly Cooperation, signed by Russia and China in 2001, failed to fully resolve the outstanding border contests. For instance, when Moscow celebrated the 160-year anniversary of the founding of Vladivostok in 2020, the state-owned China Global Television Network asserted that Vladivostok unjustly replaced the Chinese city of Haishenwai in the “unequal Treaty of Beijing” of 1860. Under immense international pressure, China’s northeastern territories of Outer Manchuria were awarded to the Russian Empire and now form Primorski Krai and a substantial part of Khabarovsk Krai.
  • 2022 July 12, Jan Kallberg, “Goodbye Vladivostok, Hello Hǎishēnwǎi!”, in Center for European Policy Analysis[21], Washington, DC, archived from the original on 2022-11-17, Europe's Edge‎[22]:
    In 1997, the First Opium War officially ended with the British administration and forces leaving Hong Kong. The Second Opium War is still ongoing, since the Russian Federation continues to occupy the Amur region and Outer Manchuria. This land area was extorted from China in 1860 during the Second Opium War, under threat to set Beijing ablaze.
    Surely no one these days thinks of returning Vladivostok to China?
  • 2023 April 12, John Bolton, “A New American Grand Strategy to Counter Russia and China”, in The Wall Street Journal[23], →ISSN, →OCLC, archived from the original on 29 April 2023, Opinion:
    Third, after Ukraine wins its war with Russia, we must aim to split the Russia-China axis. Moscow’s defeat could unseat Mr. Putin’s regime. What comes next is a government of unknowable composition. New Russian leaders may or may not look to the West rather than Beijing, and might be so weak that the Russian Federation’s fragmentation, especially east of the Urals, isn’t inconceivable. Beijing is undoubtedly eyeing this vast territory, which potentially contains incalculable mineral wealth. Significant portions of this region were under Chinese sovereignty until the 1860 Treaty of Peking transferred “outer Manchuria,” including extensive Pacific coast lands, to Moscow. Russia’s uncontrolled dissolution could provide China direct access to the Arctic, including even the Bering Strait, facing Alaska.

outer Manchuria (remote region)

  • 1917 December 30, “Japanese Activity in Shantung. Confidential Report asked for by Dr. Brown, 156 Fifth Avenue, New York City.”, in Papers Relating to Pacific and Far Eastern Affairs Prepared for the Use of the American Delegation to the Conference on the Limitation of Armament, Washington, 1921-1922[24], Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, published 1922, →OCLC, page 231:
    The Province is full of Japanese spies—surveyors, mine experts, military engineers, etc., just as in outer Manchuria, Mongolia, Fukien, and other centres. These agents in many instances secretly, but also in many instances openly, ply their trade and do as they please on the soil of a neutral people to their detriment.
  • 1918, M. W. von Bernewitz, “Gold and Silver”, in The Mineral Industry: Its Statistics, Technology and Trade[25], volume XXVI, London: Hill Publishing Company, →OCLC, page 252:
    ASIA
    China.—Conditions in this country were far from favorable for expansion of mining during 1917, and little of value is available. The mineral resources of China were reviewed by V. K. Ting.¹ Gold deposits may be divided into four classes, namely: (1) recent alluvium, (2) ancient alluvium, (3) Tertiary sandstone, and (4) quartz veins in pre-Cambrian gneiss and metamorphic rocks. The first is the most important [] In a small way the gold-bearing gneiss and phyllite are worked in Szechuan, Kiangsi, Hunan, Fukien, north Chihli, and Shantung. The Maha mine in Szechuan and the Ping-Kiang mine in Hunan occur in this class. Placer ground in Manchuria averages 1.07 dwt. gold per ton. Veins carrying under 6 dwt. are not considered profitable. Gold production of Manchuria in 1915 was 120,000 oz., and 60,000 oz. from outer Manchuria, the other provinces mentioned yielding 20,000 oz. in all.
  • 1927 May, Quincy Wright, “Bolshevist Influences in China”, in Current History[26], volume XXVI, number 2, →ISSN, →OCLC, page 302, column 2:
    Moscow doubtless wants to make trouble for the Western Powers so far as she can without losing their recognition or encouraging actual hostility. She wants peace and trade and an opportunity for internal economic reconstruction above everything just now. It seems doubtful whether she expects to Bolshevize China, though she wants China fully independent of Western imperialism and friendly to her. She doubtless hopes to retain her interests in outer Mongolia and outer Manchuria as the price of assistance to the Nationalists.
  • [1936, Proceedings - United States Naval Institute[27], volume 62, →ISSN, →OCLC, page 109, column 2:
    Meantime Japan has consistently pushed beyond Manchukuo for control of Inner Manchuria[sic – meaning Mongolia] and the adjacent Chinese province of Chahar. As a result of clashes on the Chahar-Jehol border in January, []
    [] Manchukuo, but, to quote a recent Foreign Policy Report (November 20, 1935), they would "probably elect submission to Japan rather than fight to the death for China." Japan is also pressing for a foothold in Outer Manchuria[sic – meaning Mongolia], but, in the opinion of the Report already quoted, the inhabitants there would infinitely prefer the mild tutelage and virtual independence they have enjoyed under Russian guidance to the strict control to which the []
    ]
  • 1941 July 31, “Japs War Weary, But Can't Let Go, Say Observers”, in Chicago Daily Tribune[28], volume C, number 182, →ISSN, →OCLC, page 7, column 3:
    In the north the situation is no brighter. There are now two Red armies operating in Outer Manchuria and Mongolia. These total 26 infantry divisions, 10 cavalry divisions, and four mechanized divisions. Within the last few weeks the Russians are believed to have withdrawn 10 to 12 divisions from this area.
  • 1963 September 24, William R. Kintner, “General Discussion”, in Current Strategic Thinking and Military Theory in the Communist World[29], →OCLC, page 23:
    As you may recall, in 1937 there was a major war between the Japanese and the Soviets on the edges of Outer Manchuria. The two totalitarian powers were able to control a conflict like that and use it as a means of communicating with each other without letting it get out of hand.
  • 1986, Joan Elliott Price, Ch'i Wu Shan Chin: A Li-Kuo Revival Piece of the Chin Dynasty[30], →OCLC, page 38:
    [] time the Northern Sung Imperial Painting Academy ceased to function. Hui tsung and approximately 3000 members of his court and family were exiled to outer Manchuria. According to Sung records there were 6,936 paintings at this time in the Imperial Sung collection.
  • 1996, Juha Janhunen, Manchuria: An Ethnic History[31], →ISBN, →OCLC, pages 6, 324:
    [] allowing, for certain purposes, the two subregions of Southern and Central Manchuria to be viewed as a single complex which may be termed Inner Manchuria,⁸ as opposed to the periphery or Outer Manchuria.
    Another important orographical feature is the Sikhote Alin (Sixoteh-Alin’) Range, which runs a distance of 700 miles (1,100 kms) between the Ussuri and Lower Amur basins, on the one hand, and the []
    Outer Manchuria 6 20 39 227
  • 1998, Working Paper[32], numbers 267-274, →ISSN, →OCLC, page 27:
    Zhang Xinxin was born in 1953 in Nanjing, but not long after her birth, her family moved to Beijing. Like many urban youth of her generation, she was sent to a military farm in the Great Northern Wilderness of outer Manchuria to accept education from farmers and soldiers during the Cultural Revolution in 1969. In 1979, at age twenty-six, she passed the college entrance exam and entered the Central Academy of Drama.
  • 2011, Joseph S. Nye, Jr., David A. Welch, “The Cold War”, in Understanding Global Conflict and Cooperation: An Introduction to Theory and History[33], Eighth edition, →ISBN, →LCCN, →OCLC, page 139:
    East Asia was a fourth issue. The Soviets were neutral in the Pacific until the last week of the war. Then the Soviets declared war, seizing from Japan Outer Manchuria, southern Sakhalin Island, and the entire Kurile Island chain. At Potsdam, the Soviets asked for an occupation zone in Japan, like the American occupation zone in Germany.
  • 2016, Marilyn Southard Warshawsky, “Around the World Again”, in John Franklin Goucher: Citizen of the World[34], →ISBN, →OCLC, page 275:
    The Russians had long wanted a warm-water port on the Pacific for military and commercial reasons, and in March 1898, the Chinese gave the Russian Pacific Fleet a twenty-five-year lease on the Liaotung (Liaodong) Peninsula and Port Arthur in outer Manchuria. This decision angered the Japanese because the area had been ceded to Japan by treaty after it won the Sino-Japanese War; that agreement was later rescinded, owing to intervention by Russia and other western powers. []
    Russia and Japan had both sent troops as part of an international force to quell China’s Boxer Rebellion, but after that, the Russians kept troops along the Korean border in Manchuria, which the Japanese read as a threat. Russians had also crossed into northern Korea, bought land, and established a trading post. Despite negotiations between the rivals to acknowledge Russia’s sphere of influence in outer Manchuria, and Japan’s in Korea, talks broke down early in 1904, and war soon broke out.

Generic Remote Location (like Outer Mongolia or Timbuktu)

  • 1945 December 26, “Das Ex-Kapital”, in Punch, or The London Charivari[35], volume CCIX, number 5477 (Satire), →ISSN, →OCLC, page 545, column 1:
    Not that Tackle and I had to slum with the Wardroom Mess. As distinguished emissaries we were fed and lodged by the Chief of Staff himself, whose house, which once belonged to the Ambassador of Outer Manchuria, sets an all-time high in Oriental occidentalism or vice versa. Sinful luxury is a pallid under-description of the Sino-Bavarian bathroom and the T’ang-Nazi lounge, and I am sure that had R.A.F. Intelligence been fully up to its task this pleasure dome could not have remained unbombed, a moral menace to the simple sailors who are forced to live in it.
  • 1961, John Selby, chapter 1, in Madame[36], New York: Dodd, Mead & Company, →LCCN, →OCLC, page 3:
    She was happy to sit beside the manufac- turer of beds and bedding, whose passport to this select group matched hers, only more expensively. He had given the Sidney P. Ramsbottom Science Building to Campion; this very minute it was perched on the bluff behind the chapel in all its midwestern Gothic glory. She delighted also in the presence of Chapman Orchard Hanger, the explorer just back from Patagonia, or perhaps it was Manchuria. Outer Manchuria.
  • 1968 June 12, “Raising of Money on the Credit of the Consolidates Revenue Fund”, in Legislature of Ontario Debates[37], number 116, →OCLC, page 4345, column 1:
    I am just telling you, Mr. Speaker, that the Provincial Auditor had to translate terms to me in that those public accounts, we had to make four separate calculations in order to come to that figure. Why? Should the public of Ontario not know if the government of Ontario is going in the red? Does it have to be shrouded by obfuscation? It is almost as if they hired a team of experts from Outer Manchuria to help cloud it in confusion so that you cannot tell.
  • 2004, Duncan Harding, “The Fleming Commando”, in Clash in the Baltic[38] (Fiction), Severn House, →ISBN, →OCLC, page 13:
    But by then, Fleming was sufficiently recovered from his ordeal to snarl, ‘I don’t give a fuck, old chap, whether or not they were fired from Outer Manchuria. All I want is that someone attempts to deal with their launching pads toot sweet.’